| Sat Aug 16th,2008 | Bedlington Terriers | A | FAC | 0 - 1 | |
| Sat Aug 23rd,2008 | West Allotment Celtic | A | NL | 0 - 2 | |
| Mon Aug 25th,2008 | Tow Law Town | A | NL | 2 - 3 | Draper, Home-Jackson |
| Sat Aug 30th,2008 | Seaham Red Star | A | NL | 1 - 2 | Draper |
| Wed Sep 3rd,2008 | Northallerton Town | A | NL | 1 - 1 | Craggs |
| Tue Sep 16th,2008 | South Shields | H | FAV | 3 - 1 | Price (pen), Home-Jackson (2) |
| Sat Sep 20th,2008 | Stokesley SC | A | FAV | 2 - 3 | Gardner, Draper |
| Tue Sep 23rd,2008 | Billingham Town | A | NL | 4 - 3 | Price, Gardner (2), Stewart |
| Sat Sep 27th,2008 | Shildon | H | NL | 0 - 1 | |
| Wed Oct 1st,2008 | Billingham Synthonia | A | NL | 1 - 3 | Kane |
| Sat Oct 4th,2008 | Whitley Bay | H | NL | 4 - 3 | Price, Gardner (2), Home-Jackson |
| Sat Oct 11th,2008 | Morpeth Town | H | NL | 0 - 1 | |
| Sat Oct 18th,2008 | Dunston Federation | A | NL | 3 - 3 | Armstrong (2), Gredziak |
| Wed Oct 22nd,2008 | East Durham United | A | DCC | 6 - 2 | Stewart, Gredziak, Draper (2), Price (pen), Wardle |
| Sat Oct 25th,2008 | Penrith | H | NL | 3 - 2 | Gredziak, Kane, Draper |
| Wed Oct 29th,2008 | Bedlington Terriers | A | NL | 3 - 1 | Price (2), Home-Jackson |
| Sat Nov 1st,2008 | Consett | H | NL | 4 - 2 | Price (2, 1 pen), Draper, Hassan |
| Tue Nov 4th,2008 | West Auckland Town | A | DCC | 1 - 2 | Stewart |
| Sat Nov 8th,2008 | Newcastle Benfield | H | NL | 4 - 2 | Price (2, 1 pen), Gredziak (2) |
| Tue Nov 11th,2008 | Brandon United | H | NLC | 0 - 1 | |
| Sat Nov 15th,2008 | West Auckland Town | H | NL | 0 - 0 | |
| Sat Nov 22nd,2008 | Spennymoor Town | A | NL | 2 - 2 | Stewart, Home-Jackson |
| Tue Nov 25th,2008 | Sunderland Nissan | H | NL | 1 - 2 | Home-Jackson |
| Sat Dec 20th,2008 | West Allotment Celtic | H | NL | 0 - 3 | |
| Sat Dec 27th,2008 | Tow Law Town | H | NL | 2 - 3 | Home-Jackson, Price |
| Sat Jan 3rd,2009 | Northallerton Town | H | NL | 3 - 1 | Home-Jackson, Gredziak, Price |
| Tue Jan 13th,2009 | South Shields | A | NL | 0 - 3 | |
| Sat Jan 17th,2009 | Billingham Town | H | NL | 2 - 1 | Draper, Gredziak |
| Tue Jan 27th,2009 | Whitley Bay | A | NL | 1 - 2 | Fisher |
| Sat Jan 31st,2009 | Seaham Red Star | H | NL | 4 - 0 | Armstrong, Fisher, Gredziak (2) |
| Tue Feb 10th,2009 | Ashington | A | NL | 2 - 1 | Home-Jackson, Gredziak |
| Tue Feb 17th,2009 | Ashington | H | NL | 2 - 3 | Price (pen), Home-Jackson |
| Sat Feb 21st,2009 | Bishop Auckland | H | NL | 5 - 2 | Home-Jackson, Draper (2), Fisher (2) |
| Tue Feb 24th,2009 | Bedlington Terriers | H | NL | 2 - 3 | Gredziak, Price (pen) |
| Sat Feb 28th,2009 | Shildon | A | NL | 2 - 2 | Maw, Price |
| Wed Mar 4th,2009 | Bishop Auckland | A | NL | 2 - 2 | Draper, Watson |
| Sat Mar 7th,2009 | Morpeth Town | A | NL | 2 - 1 | Robertson, Draper |
| Wed Mar 11th,2009 | Sunderland Nissan | A | NL | 3 - 2 | Robertson, Draper, Petts |
| Sat Mar 14th,2009 | Dunston Federation | H | NL | 0 - 2 | |
| Sat Mar 21st,2009 | Penrith | A | NL | 2 - 0 | Robertson, Price |
| Tue Mar 24th,2009 | Billingham Synthonia | H | NL | 1 - 0 | Allan |
| Sat Mar 28th,2009 | Consett | A | NL | 0 - 1 | |
| Tue Mar 31st,2009 | South Shields | H | NL | 1 - 1 | Price (pen) |
| Sat Apr 4th,2009 | Newcastle Benfield | A | NL | 0 - 1 | |
| Tue Apr 7th,2009 | Ryton | H | NL | 1 - 0 | Home-Jackson |
| Sat Apr 11th,2009 | West Auckland Town | A | NL | 2 - 0 | Price, Gredziak |
| Sat Apr 18th,2009 | Spennymoor Town | H | NL | 0 - 2 | |
| Sat Apr 25th,2009 | Ryton | A | NL | 2 - 3 | Home-Jackson (pen), Wake (pen) |