| Sat Aug 13th,2011 | Seaham Red Star | A | NL | 0 - 0 | |
| Tue Aug 16th,2011 | Brandon United | H | NL | 1 - 0 | Patton |
| Sat Aug 20th,2011 | South Shields | H | FAC | 1 - 1 | J. Johnson |
| Tue Aug 23rd,2011 | South Shields | A | FAC | 1 - 2 | Patton |
| Sat Aug 27th,2011 | Darlington RA | A | NL | 1 - 2 | Renwick |
| Tue Aug 30th,2011 | Birtley Town | H | NL | 1 - 2 | Renwick |
| Sat Sep 3rd,2011 | Gillford Park | A | NL | 1 - 2 | Patton |
| Tue Sep 6th,2011 | Horden CW | H | NL | 1 - 0 | Reay |
| Sat Sep 10th,2011 | Bishop Auckland | H | FAV | 3 - 5 | Reay, Evans, G. Draper |
| Tue Sep 13th,2011 | Esh Winning | A | NL | 0 - 3 | |
| Sat Sep 17th,2011 | Whickham | H | NL | 0 - 3 | |
| Sat Sep 24th,2011 | Washington | A | NL | 0 - 1 | |
| Tue Sep 27th,2011 | Team Northumbria | H | NL | 0 - 2 | |
| Sat Oct 1st,2011 | Northallerton Town | A | NL | 0 - 0 | |
| Sat Oct 8th,2011 | West Allotment Celtic | H | NL | 0 - 2 | |
| Sat Oct 15th,2011 | Thornaby | H | NL | 2 - 4 | Galer, Coghlan |
| Tue Oct 18th,2011 | Ashington | A | NLC | 1 - 0 | Swanston |
| Sat Oct 22nd,2011 | Ryton & Crawcrook Albion | A | NL | 4 - 1 | Swanston, D. Smith, Coghlan, Johnson |
| Tue Oct 25th,2011 | Morpeth Town | H | EAC | 3 - 2 | og, Patton, Johnson |
| Sat Oct 29th,2011 | Crook Town | H | NL | 0 - 1 | |
| Wed Nov 2nd,2011 | Newton Aycliffe | A | DCC | 0 - 3 | |
| Sat Nov 5th,2011 | Easington Colliery | A | NL | 3 - 0 | Patton (2), Swanston |
| Tue Nov 8th,2011 | Alnwick Town | A | NLC | 2 - 3 | Gillatt, Coghlan (pen) |
| Sat Nov 12th,2011 | Hebburn Town | H | NL | 4 - 0 | Patton (2), Coghlan, Swanston |
| Sat Nov 19th,2011 | Morpeth Town | A | NL | 2 - 3 | Wardle, Swanston |
| Sat Nov 26th,2011 | North Shields | H | NL | 1 - 1 | Swanston |
| Tue Nov 29th,2011 | Whickham | H | EAC | 2 - 5 | Curry, Vickers |
| Sat Dec 3rd,2011 | Alnwick Town | A | NL | 1 - 2 | Coghlan (pen) |
| Sat Dec 10th,2011 | Washington | H | NL | 3 - 1 | Vickers, Coghlan, Patton |
| Sat Dec 17th,2011 | Horden CW | A | NL | 4 - 3 | Wardle, Donaldson, Vickers (2) |
| Tue Dec 27th,2011 | Birtley Town | A | NL | 0 - 2 | |
| Tue Jan 3rd,2012 | Seaham Red Star | H | NL | 5 - 2 | Coghlan, Donaldson, Patton (2), Morris |
| Sat Jan 7th,2012 | Esh Winning | H | NL | 2 - 2 | Swanston, Vickers |
| Sat Jan 14th,2012 | Team Northumbria | A | NL | 1 - 5 | Swanston |
| Sat Jan 21st,2012 | Darlington RA | H | NL | 0 - 2 | |
| Sat Jan 28th,2012 | Brandon United | A | NL | 2 - 0 | Vickers (2) |
| Sat Feb 18th,2012 | Whickham | A | NL | 1 - 1 | Patton |
| Sat Feb 25th,2012 | Northallerton Town | H | NL | 1 - 1 | Fairley |
| Sat Mar 3rd,2012 | West Allotment Celtic | A | NL | 1 - 3 | Patton |
| Sat Mar 10th,2012 | Thornaby | A | NL | 2 - 2 | Proctor, D. Smith |
| Sat Mar 17th,2012 | Ryton & Crawcrook Albion | H | NL | 4 - 0 | Swanston, Fairley, Patton, Proctor |
| Sat Mar 24th,2012 | Crook Town | A | NL | 0 - 0 | |
| Tue Mar 27th,2012 | Whitehaven | A | NL | 8 - 2 | Swanston (2), L. Richardson, A. Ryan, og, Patton (3) |
| Sat Mar 31st,2012 | Easington Colliery | H | NL | 2 - 0 | Proctor (2) |
| Sat Apr 7th,2012 | Hebburn Town | A | NL | 4 - 1 | Wilson (2), Huntrod, Proctor |
| Sat Apr 14th,2012 | Morpeth Town | H | NL | 1 - 0 | Fairley (Pen) |
| Tue Apr 17th,2012 | Gillford Park | H | NL | 1 - 2 | A. Ryan |
| Sat Apr 21st,2012 | North Shields | A | NL | 1 - 0 | Wilson |
| Tue Apr 24th,2012 | Whitehaven | H | NL | 1 - 2 | K. McDonald |
| Sat Apr 28th,2012 | Alnwick Town | H | NL | 4 - 3 | Swanston (3), Patton |